New York Sports Betting Gains Ground In September; Still Annihilated By NJ

Written By Mike Mazzeo on October 20, 2021 - Last Updated on May 2, 2023
This Sept. 9, 2018 photo shows fans of the New York Giants and Jets watching a football game after placing bets in the sports betting lounge at the Ocean Casino Resort in Atlantic City, N.J. The coronavirus outbreak has added new wrinkles for bettors this year, but even so, the nation's sports books expect a record year of bets on football in 2020 from an antsy public that has been cooped up for months amid the pandemic. (AP Photo/Wayne Parry)

New York posted modest sports betting gains in September in a performance that still pales in comparison to New Jersey.

The four upstate casinos pulled in a combined $17.4 million in handle for the month, up 90% from August. Those bets yielded $3.2 million in revenue and about $318,000 in taxes to the state.

New Jersey meanwhile became the first state to eclipse the $1 billion mark for sports bets in a single month–more than 50 times as much activity as New York.

It is estimated that around a quarter of that record number comes from bettors who reside in New York.

September in NY, by the numbers

It should be noted that because of the NFL returning, September is typically a lucrative month for sportsbook operators. Indeed, handle for all four NY commercial casinos reached 2021 highs.

LicenseeHandleRevenueState Tax
Del Lago$5,431,184$1,162,877$116,288
Resorts World$2,708,185$421,525$42,153
Tioga Downs$1,253,372$188,608$18,861

In terms of total casino revenue, Rivers set a new monthly record at $17.4 million. The other three properties also performed relatively well:

  • Resorts World: $21,119,125
  • Rivers: $17,392,918
  • Del Lago: $14,183,891
  • Tioga Downs: $7,987,194

Policymakers hope to have NY online sports betting up and running in time for the Super Bowl.

New Jersey’s enviable sports betting success

Sen. Joe Addabbo expressed some frustration to PlayNY about the massive numbers out of New Jersey. But Addabbo also reiterated that the New York State Gaming Commission is on track to select applicants for licenses before Dec. 6.

Given its population advantage, New York has the potential to surpass New Jersey in sports betting handle down the road. But given these numbers, it’s certainly going to be an uphill battle.

Mike Mazzeo Avatar
Written by
Mike Mazzeo

Mike Mazzeo is a contributing writer for PlayNY, reporting on legal sports betting in New York while covering the potential legalization of NY online casinos and poker. He previously wrote for ESPN, the New York Daily News and The Ringer, among others.

View all posts by Mike Mazzeo
Privacy Policy