State attorneys general and Native American tribes are challenging proposed federal rules that would treat sports event contracts as swaps while excluding sportsbook bets and casino games. Kalshi supports the central distinction, according to InGame, highlighting a divide over how the products should be regulated.
This image was created entirely by AI with guidance from our editorial team.
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission proposed two sets of rules addressing the definition of a swap. Its approach includes both a provider test and a product test to determine whether an offering qualifies.
Attorneys General Reject The Gambling Distinction
A coalition of 44 state attorneys general and the attorney general for the District of Columbia argued that the proposed definition “rests on a legal fiction.”
Their objection centers on distinguishing gambling products based on whether customers wager against one another or against a house. The coalition said neither the Commodity Exchange Act nor judicial precedent supports dividing those products into federally regulated swaps and state-regulated casino wagers on that basis.
Dozens of tribes and tribal organizations also opposed treating sports event contracts as swaps. InGame reported that 45 tribes or tribal organizations submitted letters, almost all opposing that classification.
The Iowa Tribe of Oklahoma argued that the rulemaking would displace tribal regulatory authority and conflict with federal Indian law and Congress’s intent.
Support was not unanimous among tribes. The Tunica-Biloxi tribe of Louisiana, Alabama-Quassarte Tribal Town of Oklahoma, and California’s Alturas Indian Rancheria and Greenville Rancheria supported the rulemaking.
Kalshi Backs Rules, Seeks An Event Contract Definition
Kalshi agreed with the CFTC on the proposal’s major points but requested an explicit definition of “event contract.”
Chief Compliance Officer Sudhir Jain argued that event contracts are already “known to the trade as ‘swaps’” and that Congress intended the CFTC and Securities and Exchange Commission to have authority to further define the term.
Kalshi’s position emphasizes how an instrument is structured, bought and sold. It also supported excluding sportsbook bets and casino-style wagers that are not structured or traded as derivatives.
Several organizations that use Kalshi to hedge risk submitted comments arguing that their uses support classifying prediction-market contracts as swaps.
Private Wagers And SEC Authority Draw Questions
Polymarket US and Novig largely supported the CFTC’s plans but sought clearer exclusions for incidental wagers between friends. Their requests address how broadly the proposed definitions could reach beyond commercial platforms.
Novig proposed a narrow category for direct wagers between individuals when neither person is in the business of accepting wagers or offering exposure to others. Polymarket US sought similar language covering private wagers not offered publicly or entered through a trading facility or commercial gaming operator.
Traditional exchange operator Cboe raised concerns about securities-related contracts. General Counsel Patrick Sexton described the SEC as a “footnote” in the proposals, despite Congress authorizing the CFTC and SEC to jointly define swaps.
More from playny.com
- Nevada urges Ninth Circuit to keep Kalshi rehearing moving despite pending CFTC rules
- New York tells federal court CFTC’s Kalshi emergency order is ‘irrelevant’
- CFTC tells Kalshi, Polymarket to drop sportsbook-style odds as New York pressure builds
21+. Must be physically located in New York to bet. Gambling can be addictive and can cause harm. Gambling problem? Call 877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369).
—
Source: As reported by InGame.